top of page
tamazari logo

The Utility AI Paradox: Why Faster Adoption Isn't Delivering Greater Productivity

12 minutes ago
5 min read

Artificial intelligence is making its way into utility operations. From predicting equipment failures and analyzing grid data to improving customer service and reducing administrative work, utilities are exploring how AI can help employees work more efficiently and make better decisions. But a surprising contradiction is emerging. Deloitte's 2026 utility workforce research found that utility employees are adopting generative AI faster than the overall U.S. workforce, yet reporting less than half as much time savings. Meanwhile, the share of utility job postings requiring AI skills increased more than 44% between 2024 and 2025.[1]


The industry is embracing AI, but the productivity gains aren't keeping pace. It's a phenomenon that highlights what could be called the Utility AI Paradox. Despite growing investment, adoption, and demand for AI capabilities, utilities are not realizing the full operational benefits. The question is why. The answer appears to lie not in the technology itself, but in the systems, processes, and people surrounding it.


Why Greater AI Adoption Doesn't Guarantee Greater Productivity

For years, much of the conversation around artificial intelligence has focused on adoption. How many employees are using it? Which departments are experimenting with it? How quickly can organizations introduce new applications? Those measures can indicate progress, but they don't necessarily tell us whether AI is improving performance.


Research from the National Bureau of Economic Research illustrates the distinction. In a study involving 7,137 knowledge workers across 66 companies, employees who regularly used generative AI spent approximately two fewer hours on email each week. Yet researchers found no broader changes in the quantity or composition of their work.[2] For utilities, this distinction is especially important. When operations depend on multiple interconnected systems, departments, and established procedures, making one task faster doesn't guarantee that the overall process becomes more efficient.


Faster Tasks Don't Always Create Faster Utility Workflows

AI can identify an opportunity, but the organization's ability to act on it determines its value. Consider a utility employee reviewing hundreds of equipment inspection records. AI could potentially analyze those records, identify an emerging equipment issue, and recommend corrective action in seconds. What once required hours of manual review could become considerably faster. But what happens after the issue is identified?


If the employee must still retrieve asset information from another system, verify the recommendation, manually create a maintenance request, and coordinate with another department, much of the potential time savings may disappear. The analysis got faster. The workflow didn't.


This challenge is particularly relevant for utilities operating within complex technology environments developed over decades. Legacy platforms, specialized applications, spreadsheets, and manual processes often coexist, with information moving between systems through disconnected or inconsistent workflows. Introducing AI into that environment doesn't automatically resolve the inefficiencies already there. In fact, without corresponding changes to business processes, utilities may simply be adding another layer of technology to an already complicated operating environment.


Why Technology Isn't the Biggest Barrier to Utility AI Success

Recent research from the International Energy Agency (IEA) reinforces this challenge. In its 2026 report Modernising Grids in the Age of Electricity, the IEA examined barriers preventing electricity network operators from scaling digital technologies, including AI. Among surveyed network operators, 64% identified skills and organizational readiness as a major barrier, while 60% cited data availability and quality, and another 60% identified trust-related concerns.[3]


These barriers are interconnected. Incomplete or inconsistent data can undermine the reliability of AI-generated recommendations. When employees can't trust the information, they're less likely to use it in operational decisions. And even when the insights are accurate, disconnected systems and unclear processes can prevent teams from acting on them. Utility employees need confidence in the information AI provides, clear expectations for human oversight, and workflows that turn recommendations into meaningful action.


What Does High-Value Utility AI Adoption Look Like?

The productivity potential of AI is real. A 2025 study published in The Quarterly Journal of Economics examined more than 5,000 customer-support workers using an AI assistant. Researchers found that access to the technology increased productivity by approximately 15% on average, measured by customer issues resolved per hour.[5] Although the study was not utility-specific, it demonstrates that meaningful improvements are possible when AI supports clearly defined work activities.


For utilities, realizing similar benefits starts with examining how work gets done. Where do employees spend time transferring information between systems? Which tasks involve repetitive data entry? Where do approvals, manual handoffs, or disconnected applications delay progress?


Identifying those bottlenecks creates opportunities to redesign workflows before introducing automation. That means eliminating unnecessary steps, connecting systems so information gets where it needs to go, and giving employees the training and support to put AI-generated insights to work.


But how do utilities know whether those changes are making a difference? The number of employees using AI only tells part of the story. The real measure of success is what happens as a result. Are teams spending less time on manual tasks? Are maintenance issues being resolved faster? Are employees able to make better decisions with less effort?


Ultimately, AI's value isn't measured by how many people use it, but by what it helps them accomplish.


Utility AI Needs Modernization, Not Just More Technology

The Utility AI Paradox reflects a challenge utilities have faced through decades of digital transformation. Whether implementing ERP systems, modernizing SCADA platforms, or connecting enterprise applications, the technology itself has never been the complete solution. AI is no different.


What makes this moment significant is the opportunity to rethink how work gets done. Rather than layering AI onto existing processes, utilities can use its emergence as an opportunity to eliminate manual handoffs, improve information flow, and redesign workflows around more efficient ways of operating.


Modernize With Momentum

The Utility AI Paradox reveals an opportunity for utilities to rethink how they approach modernization. That's where Tamazari can help. Through organizational change management, systems integration, technology and user adoption, training, and workforce enablement, we help utilities bridge the gap between technology investments and operational results. Our focus goes beyond implementation to improve how systems connect, how employees work, and how organizations sustain performance after go-live.


Because the value of technology isn't measured by how quickly it's adopted, but by what it helps an organization accomplish.


About Tamazari

Tamazari is a minority-, veteran-, woman-owned professional services firm and execution consultancy serving utilities, fleet operators, public agencies and critical infrastructure organizations across the U.S. Our work spans energy IT, SCADA, GIS, ERP/SAP, enterprise modernization, telecom infrastructure, data centers and fleet telematics.


Footnotes

  1. Deloitte, The AI-Era Utility Workforce Paradox: Aging Fast While Growing Faster, September 21, 2026. View the Deloitte research

  2. Eleanor Wiske Dillon, Sonia Jaffe, Nicole Immorlica and Christopher Stanton, Shifting Work Patterns with Generative AI, National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 33795, revised November 2025. View the NBER study

  3. International Energy Agency, Modernising Grids in the Age of Electricity: Scaling Digital Technologies and AI for Better Use of Existing Networks, September 21, 2026. View the IEA report

  4. Erik Brynjolfsson, Danielle Li and Lindsey R. Raymond, Generative AI at Work, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Volume 140, Issue 2, May 2025, pp. 889–942. View the published study

 
 

Get in Touch

We provide implementation and change management services for mission-critical operations.  

Subscribe to our newsletter

832-862-5616

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page